Smith.ai or Doug? Live people on your phone vs AI that calls every lead
Which is better, Doug or Smith.ai? It depends on who you want on the phone. Pick Smith.ai if you want a live person on every call. Pick Doug if you want an AI voice that answers every call, day or night, calls every new lead in about a minute, and books the job with a Stripe deposit, on one flat price. As of September 2026, Smith.ai answers your phone line with live receptionists or an AI receptionist, billed by the call.
If you want a live person on every call, pick Smith.ai. As of September 2026, it answers your phone with live receptionists from $300 a month for 30 calls, or an AI voice agent from $150. If you want every call answered and every new lead called back in about a minute, pick Doug. He answers with an AI voice, books the job with a Stripe deposit, and costs $299 a month with 500 call minutes.
By Dylan, founder of Doug · Updated
| Doug | Smith.ai (as of September 2026) | |
|---|---|---|
| What it does | Answers every call, calls every new lead, plus texts, website chat and email | Answers your phone line |
| Who answers | Doug, with your team able to jump in | Live receptionists, or an AI receptionist |
| Price | $299 a month with 500 call minutes | Human: $300 a month for 30 calls. AI: free for 25 calls, then from $150 a month for 75 calls |
| How you pay | Flat plan, extra credits $10 per 1,000 | Per call; human plan overage is $11.50 a call |
| Booking | Included | $1.50 a call add-on on human plans |
| Deposits | Through Stripe at booking | Payment collection is a $1 a call add-on on human plans |
| Getting found on Google and in AI | Weekly check and fixes | No |
| Best for | Shops that buy leads and miss calls on the job | Businesses that want a person on every call |
Does Doug answer the phone like Smith.ai?
Yes, with an AI voice. Forward every call to Doug's number, or only the ones you can't take. He answers day or night, books the job and passes the call to you when it needs a person. Smith.ai offers live receptionists as well as an AI receptionist.
Smith.ai is a common choice for law firms and offices that want a person on every call.
What about the leads that never call?
An answering service waits for the phone to ring. Many leads never call: they come in from your website, Google, Facebook, Angi or Thumbtack, and they send the same request to three other shops. The first one to call back usually gets the job.
Doug calls those leads in about a minute, in the calling hours you set. He asks what they need and books the job. If nobody picks up, he tries once more ten minutes later.
What else does Doug do?
Doug answers from your own website, price list and documents, in whatever language the customer uses.
- Answers texts, website chat and email, as well as calls.
- Answers the questions every customer has: area, price, timing, and whether you do that kind of work.
- Takes the job details and sends them to your team.
- Books real open times and takes a deposit through Stripe.
- Runs from the AI you already use: ChatGPT, Claude, Grok Bot or Muse.
- Checks Google and AI answers every week for the questions your customers ask, and fixes what he can: service pages, your Google profile, review replies.
How do Smith.ai and Doug prices compare?
Smith.ai charges per call. Its human receptionist plans start at $300 a month for 30 calls, with extra calls at $11.50 each and add-ons billed per call: $1.50 for booking an appointment and $1 for taking a payment. Its AI receptionist is free for 25 calls, and the Pro plan starts at $150 a month for 75 calls. These are the prices on Smith.ai's pricing pages as of September 2026, so check before you buy.
Doug is a flat monthly plan. Doug is $299 a month for 10,000 credits, with calls and texts on his own number and 500 AI call minutes a month. Live handoff and custom API actions come with every paid plan. Extra credits are $10 per 1,000. Doug takes nothing off a booking payment. If you'd rather our team run the get-found work for you, done for you starts at $2,500 a month.
What does the customer end up with?
With an answering service, the customer usually ends the call with a message taken or a transfer to your team. As of September 2026, Smith.ai can also book and take intake, depending on the plan and add-ons you choose.
With Doug, the customer ends the call with an answer, a booked time, and a deposit paid when you ask for one. Your team gets the name, the number and the job details. When the question is something Doug shouldn't handle, like a billing dispute, he hands off to a person, and your team can jump into the live conversation.
Can you use both?
Yes. Some shops keep live people on the main line and give Doug the after-hours calls and the new leads. Both send you the job details, so nobody waits until morning.
If you can only pick one, count last month's leads that you called back after an hour, and the calls that went to voicemail. That count tells you what a slow answer costs you.
Questions
- Does Doug answer phone calls?
- Yes. Doug answers calls and texts on his own local number with an AI voice, books the job and passes the call to you when it needs a person.
- Is Doug cheaper than an answering service?
- Doug is $299 a month, with 500 AI call minutes in and out. Answering services usually charge per call. At 100 calls a month, a live answering service costs far more.
- Can Doug take intake like a receptionist?
- Yes. He takes the name, number and what they need, plus the job details you ask for, and sends it to your team as a lead you can act on.
- What happens when Doug can't answer?
- He says so and offers to get a person. The question shows up in your dashboard with a drafted answer, and once you approve it he gets it right from then on.
