How to follow up Angi, Thumbtack and Google LSA leads

    Reply to every paid lead within minutes, with a call and a short text, and offer a real time to come out. Thumbtack says pros who respond within 30 minutes are 25% more likely to be hired than pros who take three hours. If the customer doesn't answer, try again the same day and the next morning, then stop.

    Updated

    Key takeaways

    • Shared leads go to several pros at once, so the first useful reply usually wins.
    • Open with the job they asked about and two times you can come.
    • Try three times in about a day, by call and by text, then let the lead go.
    • Track cost per booked job by source, not cost per lead.

    Why do paid leads need a faster reply than your own leads?

    A customer who calls you from your own website picked you. A customer who fills in a request on Angi or Thumbtack often hears from several pros, so you are in a race from the first second. Google Local Services Ads work more like a direct call, but Google ranks you partly on how fast and how often you answer.

    The lead sites track this. Thumbtack measures your response rate, uses it for its Pro Rewards tiers, and said at its 2025 Pro Summit that a reply within 30 minutes makes a pro 25% more likely to be hired than a reply within three hours. Google's Local Services Ads help page lists responsiveness and average response time as ranking factors.

    What should the first reply say?

    Answer the request they wrote, not a generic greeting. A good first call or text covers four things:

    • Who you are, in one line: 'Hi Sarah, this is Mike from Oak Street Plumbing.'
    • The job, in their words: 'You asked about a leaking water heater in Mesa.'
    • One question that moves it forward: 'Is it leaking from the top or the bottom?'
    • Two real times: 'I can come today at 4 or tomorrow at 8. Which works?'

    How many times should you follow up?

    Call first, because a call that connects books more jobs. If they don't answer, send the text at once so they have something to reply to. Try again in the afternoon or evening, and once more the next morning. Three tries in about a day covers most people who were really shopping.

    After that, stop. More texts to a lead who went quiet look like spam, and the lead sites can mark you down for it. A lead who books someone else is not a failure in your follow-up. A lead who never heard from you is.

    How do you reply fast when you are on a job?

    This is where most shops lose paid leads. The alert arrives while you are in a crawl space, and by the time you call back, two other pros already have. A few fixes, from simplest to most complete:

    • Turn on the lead apps' notifications on one phone and give one person the job of first reply.
    • Write saved replies for your five most common jobs, so a text takes ten seconds.
    • Set the lead sites' own auto-reply, and still follow up in person, since an auto-reply asks but doesn't book.
    • Forward the lead emails to an AI agent that calls and books for you.

    How do you tell if paid leads are worth the money?

    Cost per lead is the wrong number. Track cost per booked job for each source: what you spent on Angi last month, divided by the jobs you booked from it. Do the same for Thumbtack, Google LSA and your own website. A source with expensive leads that you book often can beat one with cheap leads that never answer.

    Faster follow-up changes this math more than any bid change. If you book 3 out of 10 paid leads today and a faster reply moves that to 4, every lead got 33% cheaper without spending a dollar more.

    How does Doug follow up paid leads?

    Forward your Angi, Thumbtack and Google lead emails to Doug's address. He reads each one, saves the lead, and calls the customer in about a minute, inside the calling hours you set. He opens with the job they asked about, answers questions from your own prices and service area, and books a real time on your calendar. If nobody picks up, he tries once more ten minutes later.

    Your Home page shows every lead, how fast Doug answered and which ones booked. Doug is $299 a month with 500 call minutes. Try him 7 days free.

    Questions

    How fast should I respond to a Thumbtack lead?
    Within minutes. Thumbtack's own data says a reply within 30 minutes makes you 25% more likely to be hired than a reply within three hours.
    Does response time affect Google Local Services Ads ranking?
    Yes. Google's help page lists responsiveness and average response time among the factors it uses, and says missed calls may hurt your responsiveness.
    Should I call or text an Angi lead first?
    Call first, then text at once if they don't pick up. The text gives them an easy way to reply when they can.
    Can Doug reply inside the Angi or Thumbtack app?
    Doug works from the lead emails those sites send. When the lead has a phone number, he calls it from your business number, so the reply reaches the customer directly.

    Sources

    Terms in this guide

    Keep reading

    Someone is asking Google and ChatGPT who to call right now.

    Start free (7 days)

    Cancel anytime. Or try him on your site first.