How fast should a contractor call back a new lead?
Call a new lead back within five minutes if you can, and always within the hour. In a Harvard Business Review audit of 2,241 US companies, firms that replied within an hour were nearly seven times as likely to reach a decision maker as firms that waited longer. A homeowner with a broken AC books the first shop that calls with a time.
Updated
Key takeaways
- Aim for a callback in five minutes. Treat one hour as the hard limit.
- Most leads that go cold are never refused. Someone else simply called first.
- Google ranks Local Services ads partly on how fast you respond, so slow replies also cost you future leads.
- Measure your real response time for two weeks before you change anything.
Why does the first shop to call usually get the job?
Think about how a homeowner hires for a repair. The water heater is leaking, so they search, fill in two or three forms and maybe call one number. They are not comparing proposals. They want someone who can come, at a price that sounds fair, soon. The first shop that calls with a real time slot answers all three questions at once, and the homeowner stops shopping.
Bigger jobs move slower, but the pattern holds. A homeowner pricing a new roof or a panel upgrade still tends to book the estimate with the company that called while they were paying attention. Two hours later they are at work, at dinner, or already talking to someone else.
What does the research on lead response time show?
The best known study is 'The Short Life of Online Sales Leads', published in Harvard Business Review in March 2011 by James Oldroyd, Kristina McElheran and David Elkington. They sent test inquiries to 2,241 US companies and timed the replies.
- Firms that tried to reach the lead within an hour were nearly seven times as likely to have a real conversation with the decision maker as firms that waited even one more hour.
- They were more than 60 times as likely to qualify the lead as firms that waited 24 hours or longer.
- 23% of the companies never replied at all, and the average first reply among those that did took 42 hours.
What do Thumbtack and Google say about response time?
The lead sites measure speed and reward it. At its 2025 Pro Summit, Thumbtack said pros who respond to a lead within 30 minutes are 25% more likely to be hired than pros who respond within three hours. Thumbtack also tracks your response rate and uses it for its Pro Rewards tiers.
Google's own help page for Local Services Ads lists 'your responsiveness to customer inquiries and requests' as a ranking factor, and says missed calls may count against it. Average response time is also part of your profile quality. A slow reply costs you the lead in front of you and pushes your ad down for the next one.
How do you measure your own speed to lead?
Most owners guess their response time and guess low. For two weeks, write down when each lead arrived, when someone spoke to them or gave a real answer, and whether the job booked. An autoresponder that says 'we got your message' doesn't count.
Split the log into three groups: business hours, evenings and weekends, and the busy hours when everyone is on a job. The last two groups are usually where the slow replies and lost jobs are. Then call five leads you didn't book and ask who they went with and why. You will hear 'they called first' more than you expect.
How can a small shop call every lead in five minutes?
A one-truck shop can't stop a job every time a form comes in, and a shop with an office still has lunch breaks, busy Mondays and evenings. These are the options, from cheapest to most complete:
- Put new-lead alerts on one phone, with one person who owns the first call during business hours.
- Send a fast text from that phone when a call isn't possible: who you are, that you saw the request, and two times you could come.
- Pay a live answering service to call web leads back. Most bill by the call or the minute, and few work Angi or Thumbtack leads.
- Use an AI agent that calls every new lead itself, asks what they need and books a time on your calendar.
How does Doug call new leads?
Doug calls each new lead from your website, Google, Facebook, Angi or Thumbtack in about a minute, inside the calling hours you set. He asks what they need from your own answers on area, prices and timing, and books a real open time from your calendar or set hours, with a Stripe deposit if you want one. If nobody picks up, he tries once more ten minutes later.
He also answers every call you forward to him, day or night, plus texts and website chat. Each lead lands in your inbox with the conversation attached, so you see how fast he answered and what was booked. Doug is $299 a month with 500 call minutes. Try him 7 days free.
Questions
- What is a good lead response time for a home service business?
- Under five minutes is the target. Under an hour is the limit. Past an hour, the Harvard Business Review data shows your odds of reaching the customer fall fast.
- Is a text as good as a call?
- A text beats silence, and some customers prefer it. A call with a real time slot usually books more jobs, because it answers the price and timing questions in one go.
- What about leads that come in at night?
- Call them first thing in the morning, before other shops open. Doug calls inside the hours you set, 8 AM to 9 PM at most, so an 11pm lead is first in line at 8 AM.
- Does speed matter for big jobs like roofs and HVAC replacements?
- Yes. The homeowner still books the estimate with whoever reaches them first. The sale takes longer, but the first visit usually goes to the fastest shop.
